Showing posts with label Standing on the Side of Love. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Standing on the Side of Love. Show all posts

Monday, October 3, 2011

"Immigration As A Moral Issue"


© Rev. Susan Karlson

Unitarian Church of Staten Island

September 18, 2011

This sermon is dedicated to the Rev. Dr. Jeremy Taylor, community minister, dreamweaver, colleague and friend, who has inspired my ministry and journey toward wholeness for 14 years with his "if it were my dream" approach to dream work. Blessings to him in his life journey and his ministry of love and wholeness.

I had a dream the other night about otherness. Many of my dreams take place at a retreat or conference and I know from this epiphany what the dream has come to teach me. In this dream, some wise women speak, saying, “go to other rooms and experience what it means to be “the other”, the stranger, the one who feels marginalized.”

In the waking world, when I am feeling “different”, I just want to escape those feelings, to turn my back on those other people whom I perceive are rejecting me. In turn, to ward off the pain, I reject them. This is a pattern our psyches take that is difficult to see in action. I try not to enact this pattern but sometimes my fears get the best of me.

Unitarian Universalists often take some pride in being open, inclusive and welcoming. But perhaps that makes it more difficult for us to realize that we, too, make people into “the other”. In the case of immigration, we know who the “bad guys” are, don’t we? Well, sometimes, we make assumptions. It’s the conservative politicians who oppose justice and equity. It’s the border patrol agents who pour out the water bottles left for parched souls or the ones who hunt each immigrant crossing the desert, pregnant, sick, dying of thirst. It’s the ICE officials or the immigration officials. Maybe, our image of them is that they have no mercy or compassion in their hearts at all.

Though Unitarian Universalism calls us to see the inherent worth and dignity of every person, it’s easy to vilify people who can be seen as standing on the side opposing love. And if we hear the very real human stories like Ravi’s (Ravi works with the New Sanctuary Coalition in New York City) and Norma’s (Norma is a member of the New York State Leadership Youth Council) and we work with immigrants or our friends are immigrants or we simply read the news, we might get a little puffed up, that we are the ones standing on the side of love—while “others” are not.

This really came home to me when my clergy colleagues and I met with various rather conservative elected officials about our concerns for those living in poverty and the treatment of immigrants. I am not sure that those politicians changed their minds but there was an openness to really listen and to welcome our input. And frankly, it shocked me. We may not share views on scarcely any issue but I needed to meet them personally and not get my impressions solely through the media or hearsay, not to deny their humanity. This is a spiritual practice I return to over and over again.

I began thinking about a tendency among religious liberals to hang out only with those who agree with us on specific issues. It’s easier to be in dialogue with those who think, feel and act as we do but how does anything ever change if we only count our friends as those who are exactly like us?

And so it is with Immigration as a moral issue. For myself, I need to hear from our friends like those from El Centro del Inmigrante what they are facing. I need to feel my heart break for Norma whose parents could be deported or Ravi whose child watches her father humiliated and handcuffed with no idea when it could happen again.

And then, one of my dear colleagues faces deportation at any moment. He is a colleague who spoke at this church. He has brought understanding, peace and harmony among factions in this community. And yet, he may be forced to leave for no reason. He is not an “other”—I know him, I have prayed with him. I have heard him speak under the light of candles, I have known his pain and his joy and heard his wise, compassionate counsel. It’s hard not to demean those that I perceive are doing this to him, to all of us on Staten Island that need his presence and his love. Yet it is not “others” who are doing this—it is the immigration system that is in sore need of repair.

It is the system and people’s actions within that system that is reprehensible, that tears families asunder, that has few compassionate provisions for the human family. It is the racial, economic, social, religious and political gatekeepers that act on that system’s behalf to keep out certain immigrants from specific countries whose governments we oppose while letting in a plethora from countries whose governments and dictators we support (at least for a time).

In Death of Josseline are stories of those that cry out to us for justice and the stories of those doling out the injustices. I ask myself as part of my spiritual practice, “Can I see the fear and the concerns that the “unjust” have in their hearts? Do they fear losing a job, a way of life? Do they fear becoming “an other”?” I need to hear their stories, too.

I am not saying that all views are equal. They are not. You heard that clearly in our Call to Community when the president of the Unitarian Universalist Association, the Rev. Peter Morales, held up the difference between legal and moral rights.

A thorough understanding of all sides of the issues will not negate the need for comprehensive immigration reform; likely the commitment will be greater. I believe in the non-violent compassionate and empathic approaches of Gandhi, Martin Luther King and Cesar Chavez, in the faith that sustained them no matter what happened to them or those that labored alongside them in the fields of justice and human rights. Deep down this is a moral struggle. Don’t each of us know what is “wrong”, legal or not? We are strengthened through our moral and spiritual integrity when we stand for immigrant’s rights, acting in solidarity with and accountability to people of color who have been oppressed since the founding of this country, or the many who are immigrants from countries still crippled by colonization. We need not be apologetic or conditional about that solidarity, whatever form it takes.

There are broader moral issues—I may be conditioned to turn adversaries and opponents into an “other”. Even more, deep in my heart and soul, I believe that I am called to take the anger I feel and transform it into love and justice. When someone we love—our children, our partners, those closest to us—infuriate us, we still love them. How can we acknowledge the anger we feel and change it into something that makes our communities more harmonious, compassionate and peaceful, less violent?

One of our members said that there are people in this congregation whose work is to help immigrants yet they feel that when they come to this church they are told they should do more. Let me be clear about my theology. I know full well that there are people in this church who work with the legal system and try to insure every single day that their clients who come from diverse countries get a fair hearing and have enough resources to survive. Would I say they need to do more? Absolutely not. I celebrate their calling to work in the trenches for justice.

There are others of you who work with clients living in poverty or in schools or colleges that are largely immigrant populations. You are doing everything you can to make sure that those clients and students get a fair shake. We are all standing on the side of love, doing what we can, trying to understand, trying to make this world a better place, part of this church’s mission. It’s enough. It’s simply enough.

Yet, for me, as a Unitarian Universalist minister, I have a deep yearning to see this congregation, to see my chosen faith, use its power, its resources, its energy to collectively reform the immigration system so that it’s more compassionate, just and honest. Even a church as small as ours with limited resources, people and time can have far more influence on the immigration system than one person speaking or acting individually as powerful as one person can be.

That is why Ravi and Norma are with us today as representatives of their worthy organizations, not because we don’t do enough, not because we aren’t enough but because we need to figure out how to harness our energy, to understand what calls to us about this broken immigration system that is destroying lives and weakening the moral fiber of American life.

Our forum today on “Immigration As a Moral Issue”, the congregational study action issue of Unitarian Universalist congregations across this nation, gives us another opportunity to “go to other rooms and experience what it means to be “the other”, the stranger, the one who feels marginalized.” May we find the compassion and moral integrity that leads to justice; that brings peace, inner and outer peace. Amen. May it be so.

Monday, February 14, 2011

"Equal Hearts—No Borders Can Confine Our Hearts"

© Rev. Susan Karlson
February 13, 2011

Valentine’s Day used to be my least favorite holiday—I felt lonely and sad each Valentine’s Day when I didn’t have a loving relationship. I know the greeting card extravaganza and the hype about this holiday of love has that impact on many people just like Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Thanksgiving and every other holiday. My message this morning is about standing on the side of love.

Alan and I will celebrate our tenth wedding anniversary this year. I remember when he proposed to me during Joys and Sorrows, what we call Milestones here. He prearranged with the musician to get the whole congregation to join in singing, “Susan, Susan, give me your answer do”, changing the name in the song, Bicycle Built For Two. And I tell you that the congregation sang more enthusiastically and joyfully during that proposal song than I’d ever heard them sing before. It was a true celebration of the love that wafts through a community and how much people love to see people in loving relationships.

Alan and I planned two wedding ceremonies—the first that allowed me, a self employed social worker with some pre-existing medical conditions, to start receiving the medical health insurance of his employer. That first wedding was small, just our mothers, my daughter, my maid of honor and a beloved Unitarian Universalist minister and mentor, and his wife.

Our second wedding ceremony was the church wedding that many members of our home church attended. Alan wanted us to dance down the aisle at the end of the ceremony. I told him I’d much rather preach before a thousand people. I love to dance but the idea of waltzing down the aisle made me jittery. In an uncharacteristic plea, he pointed out that he had been open to my ideas and I should at least consider his wishes. We took ballroom dancing lessons soon after that and did indeed dance down the aisle to the tune of “May I have this dance for the rest of our lives?”

So I love weddings. I love romance and expressions of love and affection. Love receives top billing in my scheme of life. Love is the adhesive that affixes people through the exhilarating highs, the broken, shattered moments of their family lives and all the times in-between.

Each time I met with a couple or a family when I was a therapist, each time I meet with a couple planning to marry and hear something about their families and their experiences I glimpse that spark of commitment, that mysterious presence of something we acknowledge when it comes to us but that we can’t make appear. Love is pure grace—it just happens. When I meet with couples and ask how they picked this person to marry out of all the people in the world, they usually get very quiet—tears well up in their eyes. You can see them entering some vast reservoir, an ocean of love that has changed them. They seem to enter some deep meditative place and sort out what the person sitting next to them means in the totality of their lives. Each person says something different but their reflections are always revealing of the power of love and commitment. I consider it one of the greatest privileges of being a minister to witness these cycles of life and love in the human heart.

Practically, marriage also helped Alan and I financially--my ability to get on his health plan is a benefit same sex couples in most states cannot receive. That is one of the 1324 benefits of New York state laws which protect and sanction married couples but which are denied to same-sex couples.

I became an ardent straight ally at the time of my first called ministry in Wilmington, North Carolina. I was invited to participate in a television panel discussing the election of Episcopalian Bishop Eugene Robinson, who was openly gay. Next, I learned about two New York Unitarian Universalist clergy charged with performing illegal marriages for same sex couples. A member of my congregation asked if I thought we should do something about it. Together the Unitarian Universalist congregation launched a grassroots community coalition for marriage equality.

I joined the state Religious Coalition for Marriage Equality where I met a brave Methodist minister who was unable to retain his fellowship as a minister because he married same sex couples. I also met clergy from Pullen Memorial Baptist church, a church that had done a research into the Bible verses that are often used against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people. Their published findings did not back up the biblical prejudice and condemnation of LGBT people.

My best friend in Wilmington was the first person outside the church I met—Russell Heiland, a minister at Unity Church. He and his husband, Anthony Izzell, often invited Alan and I to watch the sun go down over the Cape Fear River waterfront. Sometimes, we got together to see rather unorthodox plays for ministers like Rocky Horror Picture Show.

When Russ became the senior minister at Unity, he paid me the greatest compliment—he asked me to preach at his ordination. Both of these men became our closest couple friends. To say that I love Russell and Anthony is an understatement. Russell was the minister at my mother’s memorial service. We are close colleagues and the best of friends.

I understand that change takes time. I know people often think we should just have civil unions so the laws will pass more quickly. Referring to someone as a partner is not the same as calling them a spouse, husband or wife. Besides denying people the portability of marriage from state to state and all the rights and privileges of marriage, it also creates a differentiation in how we sanction marriage and how we view commitments between same sex partners. The old “separate but equal” idea never worked for African Americans in the Civil Rights era and it doesn’t work with marriage equality either. Russell and Anthony have been together for about twenty years. They share a love and commitment to weather the same storms of life heterosexual couples face; their love is as real and deep as any I have known. Knowing these two fine men how can I act with integrity and not commit to do whatever I can to speak up for marriage equality?

I had learned some years before when the New York Unitarian Universalist clergy were charged that some Unitarian Universalist ministers refused to sign marriage certificates for heterosexual couples until all couples willing to make the commitment, could marry. I struggled with my conscience for 3 ½ years. I told a bit of this story during the Martin Luther King service last month—about when I couldn’t sleep and awoke in the middle of the night, wrestling with the decision whether I would continue to act as an agent of the state and sign marriage certificates when my faith and my ministry affirms love between two men and two women as equally sacred and binding. In the early hours of the morning, I read Martin Luther King’s Letter from the Birmingham Jail. Something clicked for me, reading how colleagues wanted King to slow down and take it easy. I realized I couldn’t do that any longer. I had this cloud of witnesses surrounding me and their love was reaching into my own heart.

A few years back, Alan’s oldest daughter, Jessica, met her beloved, Jen, at college. Their relationship has deepened and they recently moved to the West Coast so that Jessica can pursue graduate studies. Jessica and Jen plan to marry and they want me to officiate at their wedding. What an honor. But Jessica and Jen live in a state that doesn’t allow same sex couples to marry as do I and all our families. By officiating at their ceremony I can commend them to love and cherish one another, to stand beside one another no matter what life brings but nothing I can do or say or sign can confer on them the same rights and privileges that Jessica’s father and I enjoy. There is a little piece of my heart that breaks with that awareness.

And so, you see, I am wed to working for marriage equality. Same sex couples in this church cannot marry legally in this wonderful state. My call to minister with the good people of this church and to officiate during wedding ceremonies did not include treating same sex couples and their desire to commit and care for one another differently. How is their love any less than anyone else’s? I know it takes time for people to understand what is at stake. I know that marriage equality will be a reality—it’s a matter of time. But how many couples are unable to stand by the bedside of their beloved in the hospital as they lay dying, or have medical personnel refuse to allow parents to accompany their child who is having trouble breathing? How many times will same sex couples have to pay tax on their health insurance benefits from their partner or have to pay estate taxes when their spouse dies, taxes that no married heterosexual couple has to pay?

This two-tier system of marriage has to end and I will sincerely work to end it this year. Three of us from this church went to the Marriage Equality Advocacy Day this past Tuesday to visit our State Senators Savino and Lanza. We met with their staff people as well as Representative Nicole Malliotakis. All of them asked to know the laws that create a difference in the civil rights afforded to gay and lesbian couples. I have here the large bundle of 1324 statutes that impact the everyday lives of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people.

This past year there have been successes for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender people—the “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy was repealed, GENDA legislation impacting employment discrimination and protection for transgender people was favored. Yet MARRIAGE INEQUALITY remains.

Let’s stand on the side of love and justice by making valentines urging Sen. Lanza and Rep. Malliotakis to support Marriage Equality and thanking Rep. Titone and Sen. Savino for all they have done to bring marriage equality closer.

Each of you in this Sanctuary knows a committed LGBT couple or you are in a LGBT relationship yourself. Those couples need vocal straight allies. Let us add our voices to the call for unbounded Love for everyone.

Monday, December 13, 2010

NYC Standing on the Side of Love Immigration Rally Dec. 9th

It was a cold day in New York City as we prepared to rally in front of Governor Patterson's office. This was the latest in a series of events in New York City that have focused on immigrant's rights and reform, the passage of the Dream Act and responses to the increase in enmity and attacks on Latinos and people with various racial, ethnic, religious and LGBTQ identities. Standing on the Side of Love with people from Make the Road New York, the New York Immigrant Coalition, and people from many different faiths and backgrounds, I renewed my commitment to building partnerships and coalitions. Yesterdays' Rally was part of the essential struggle for immigrant rights. Here in New York, if someone is stopped for the most minor of offenses, like a parking violation, they can be detained and the New York police, whose duty it is to keep the peace and assure the safety of all persons, are often called to turn over people suspected of being undocumented. So many families are separated and parents deported. The police cannot safeguard the general public with their dual role as police and immigration officers. And many undocumented immigrants do not report crimes or injuries out of fear of deportation and their families being torn apart.

When I first learned of these practices, I thought they parallel Arizona SB 1070! All of us in this country are in danger of having draconian practices, policies and laws with the ignited fears and prevalent myths about immigrants. In spite of temperatures in the 20's, a number of Unitarian Universalists gathered in Manhattan found our spirits warmed as we "stood on the side of love" in solidarity with many other groups.

The strength of our Standing on the Side of Love advocacy and witness efforts is its broad based appeal to many faiths and community organizations. Standing on the Side of Love means that my colleague and friend, Gonzalo Mercado, from El Centro del Inmigrante, noted, "I see you more often here in Manhattan than on Staten Island." He knows he can count on me because of the relationships we are building. Later that evening at an Anti Bias Summit on Staten Island, we talked about ways the Unitarian Church of Staten Island can increasingly work with El Centro and other immigrant groups. He expressed his affection for our church and I assured him that we feel a real connection with El Centro. There will be many more Rallies, phone calls, Summits and times when we work together on deepening the bonds of love and justice between us. That is the power of Standing on the Side of Love during this chilly time of year, or the excruciating heat of the summer just past and all other seasons in between. ~The Rev. Susan Karlson, Minister, Unitarian Church of Staten Island

Friday, June 11, 2010

Reflection on Immigration Reform and my NYC civil disobedience

The Unitarian Church of Staten Island that I serve has focused many of its Standing on the Side of Love services on immigration this year—inviting speakers from the Liberian and Sri Lankan communities, and from organizations like El Centro del Inmigrante and Make the Road New York. A central charge of the Staten Island Clergy Leadership group has been to address the alarming rise in anti-immigrant violence fueled by ignorance and fear. So when I learned of the act of civil disobedience planned to encourage the Obama administration to finally make comprehensive reform of immigration policy a top priority I committed myself to a personal act in support of my beliefs.

As 56 of us linked arms and walked into the street to block traffic in front of the Federal Plaza where many immigrants and their families face deportation every day we sang We Shall Overcome. There were taunts from others who opposed our action, but I felt the strong cloud of witnesses to justice in whose line we stood. For me, it was a reaffirmation of my commitment to be a white ally and my calling to the Unitarian Universalist ministry, which was forged in the anti-racism work of our Association. Those of us willing to be arrested were treated well by the police and the judicial system. I know that the many immigrants arrested each day know real fear as families are shattered by immigration and naturalization policies and practices that reinforce a system of “us” and “them”. We risked very little on this one day while immigrants risk being deported, losing their jobs and being treated like criminals every day. Arizona SB 1070 and other bills of this sort will only fuel more violence, racism, distrust and fear.

Members of my congregation individually work tirelessly for legal and social services to immigrants in New York City and Staten Island. They are witnesses to the daily tragedy for immigrants in all the boroughs of New York City.

As a result of my act of civil disobedience and the church reaching out to immigrant communities this year, immigration coalitions are hoping that we will act in solidarity with them to make Staten Island a safer, healthier and more just place to live. I believe we can make a difference if together we stand on the side of love and justice.

http://standing-firm.chttp://standing-firm.com/

Rev. Susan Karlson in the yellow Standing on the Side of love t shirt with the purple stole on the left behind the men in orange shirts.

Participants released the following joint statement concerning today’s civil disobedience action:
“Being conscientiously of opinion that our current immigration laws betray our core principles of democracy, inclusiveness and justice; that they allow for Arizona’s immoral and unconstitutional SB1070; and that their continued enforcement through detention and deportation separates families and destroys communities; we are compelled to escalate our call for Comprehensive Immigration Reform in the face of inaction from our nation’s elected representatives.
“Today we stand in solidarity with the millions who contribute to our communities and economy while being denied full access to them. Our act of civil disobedience is performed with the belief that our laws can—and should—be better, and that our nation’s leaders cannot stand on the sidelines as our society’s core values are betrayed by a broken and immoral immigration system.
“We invite the enforcement of the law upon ourselves in the hope that our arrest today will be the catalyst for principled leadership from the President and Congress and for meaningful Comprehensive Immigration Reform that will put an end to the arrests and other mistreatments faced by our friends, families, congregations, and communities.”
—Unity Statement Signed by Those Arrested